Sunk costs

Minnesota gets a ‘D’ for wind and solar decommissioning requirements.

Happy Monday! This week, I’m republishing one of my final pieces written for Center of the American Experiment’s Winter 2026 edition of Thinking Minnesota magazine. You can check out the National Center for Energy Analytics report and see where your state ranks on their requirements for decommissioning wind and solar. American Experiment also republished my piece, “The Myth of Cheap Wind and Solar.”

In case you missed it, the Administration has decided to require PJM Interconnection to “hold a power auction offering tech companies and data centers the opportunity to bid for 15-year contracts for new electricity generation capacity.” I’m fascinated — my gut says more government intervention won’t be good for the grid. And a bipartisan group of legislators is introducing a bill to create a $2.5 billion critical minerals stockpile. That couldn’t come soon enough for U.S. national security.

Minnesota gets a ‘D’ for wind and solar decommissioning requirements

The National Center for Energy Analytics (NCEA) released “A State-by-State Assessment of Financial Assurances Required for Decommissioning Wind and Solar Facilities” in October 2025. This report evaluates each state’s financial assurances required for decommissioning wind and solar facilities. The NCEA defines decommissioning as “the process of removing physical structures and restoring a site back to its original or usable condition.” Given the short lifespans of wind turbines and solar panels — only 20 to 25 years or so — the first wave of hardware is approaching the end of their useful lives now. The sorry fact is that many states have neglected to “address and account for” the decommissioning process, leaving taxpayers and ratepayers exposed to the financial risks of dismantling these wind and solar facilities.

Standard practice is for the facility operator to pay for decommissioning, but because the financial viability of the original owners is not guaranteed in the future, states tend to require financial guarantees for anticipated decommissioning costs. Oil and gas drilling and nuclear plants have long had these requirements, but the NCEA’s analysis is one of the first to systematically evaluate the 50 states for their decommissioning rules for wind and solar facilities.

According to the report, 30 states received a failing grade (D or F) for their renewables decommissioning requirements, with Minnesota receiving a D. In contrast, 25 states received an A for oil and gas well decommissioning, with only one state failing.

In Minnesota, wind applicants must:

submit a plan that includes the estimated decommissioning costs “in current dollars,” a method and schedule for updating these costs, and an assurance that the funds will be available for decommissioning. It appears that this is an “as approved” standard, not a preset standard.

In Minnesota, “solar appears to be local. For example, Center City’s regulation requires financial resources to be available to fully decommission the site. To obtain a grant, the locality should submit to the state government the cost of decommissioning.”

The NCEA report for Minnesota concludes that:

For wind, everything is discretionary. While it appears that the regulations are trying to establish financial assurance, nothing is firmly required. For solar, local regulations permit the amount of financial assurance to be self-determined.

Neighboring North Dakota also received a D, as the financial assurance for wind and solar decommissioning is not required until after construction and the costs are capped to not exceed 25 percent of the owners’ tangible net worth. NCEA notes that this cap could “potentially limit the amount to less than the cost of decommissioning,” exposing taxpayers to potential costs.

The NCEA estimates the decommissioning costs to Minnesota of all existing facilities and those planned through 2030 to cost $628 million. The anticipated costs of decommissioning all installed and planned capacity through 2030 in North Dakota would cost $435 million.

This isn’t a theoretical concern. The cost to decommission wind and solar facilities ranges from $30 million to over $100 million per 1,000 megawatts of capacity, according to the NCEA report. These costs land on the taxpayer if the original company goes bankrupt, which happens all too often in the wind and solar industry.

This piece was originally published in the Winter 2026 edition of Thinking Minnesota, Center of the American Experiment’s in-house magazine.